An international scholarly online history journal on First and Second Empire subjects: articles, bibliographies, book reviews, in english and in french
EN FRANÇAIS


THE MAGAZINE / NEWS

Magazine and News is a place where, every day, we bring you not only what’s going on in the Napoleonic world and interviews with those leading Napoleonic history today, but we also offer you Napoleonic pastimes, entertainments, and even recipes. Enjoy!

Latest updates :

Bon appetit! : Turkey in the form of a turtle
Musique et parole : An introduction to First Empire music
Interview : Alexander Mikaberidze on Russian Voices of the Napoleonic Wars
anglegauche angledroit
 
 

PRESS REVIEW

Recent articles published elsewhere on First and Second Empire themes.
To add an entry to your «My napoleon.org » account, click on the title(s) and then select «Add to my account».

For information concerning this section, contact us here.

The Lines of Wellington: Review

On 27 September, 1810, having beaten Busaco, Massena was on his way to Lisbon. Already on the defensive, Wellington was strengthening his position and protecting his forces behind a  formidable network of fortifications he had built: the famous lines of Torres Vedras. The French, commanded by Massena, were ignorant of their existence. The confrontation of the French with the lines of Torres Vedas provides the backdrop to Valeria Sarmiento's The Lines of Wellington.

The film was the project of Franco-Chilean director Raúl Ruiz, who sadly died before the film was fully completed. Sarmiento picked up where he left off, and does a convincing job of finishing the film. It features an international cast and stars French, American, English and Portuguese actors - creating a film bursting with individual histories and destinies, from the battle at Busaco to Massena's confrontation of the lines at Torres. More than a simple reenactment of the battle, the film asks us to reflect on the fates of its characters, on violence, death, war and love. Readers who are expecting a film about the Napoleonic wars should be warned that Sarmiento is no Bondarchuk; there aren't great battle scenes here, but rather descriptions recounted by the "heroes" of the tragedy. This does not detract from the overall quality of the film: the focus on the characters, their stories and their vagaries in a ravaged country is what grips the viewer. The film is focussed primarily on characters outside of the ranks, but we encounter Wellington (John Malkovich), Massena (Melvil Poupeau) Marbot (Mathieu Amalric), Segur (Malik Zidi), cannon fire and gun shots, as well as fanatical priests and ambushes.
Our only criticism: the film is a little long, especially the last half an hour, which seems repetitive. In any case, it's a film well worth watching.

 
- Thierry Lentz


 
     
 
 

 Back to homepage

 Back to the section homepage

 Back to the heading homepage

 

 

 Consult this week's and previous Press Reviews

 

 

 Imprimer

Add to your selection

 

 

See the press review for

 OK

 See this week's press review


 

Top of the page

Bulletin | My Napoleon.org | Site Map | Contact us | Add to your favourites | Legal | ISSN 2272-1800